2009 Toyota Siennavs 2009 Kia Carnival
Side-by-side reliability comparison based on NHTSA owner complaints
The 2009 Kia Carnival is the most reliable choice with a Klunk Score of 100/100 ("Smooth Ride"). The 2009 Toyota Sienna has 207 owner complaints and 0 NHTSA recalls. The 2009 Kia Carnival has 0 owner complaints and 0 NHTSA recalls.
2009 Toyota Sienna
53 /100
Proceed with Caution
2009 Kia Carnival
100 /100
Smooth Ride
Winner
Head to Head
| 2009 Toyota Sienna | 2009 Kia Carnival | |
|---|---|---|
| Klunk Score | 53/100 | 100/100 |
| Complaints | 207 | 0 |
| Recalls | 0 | 0 |
| Verdict | Proceed with Caution | Smooth Ride |
Complaints by Category
2009 Toyota Sienna
Body 144
Electrical 39
Engine 17
Transmission 4
Brakes 3
2009 Kia Carnival
No complaints on record